Posted: Tue Dec 30, 2008 12:51 pm
Cap'n: Not quite. The Harmony works perfectly and completely, including these three commands. (If it didn't, I can learn anything I need to off of the original remote, anyhow.) I personally am completely squared away. Rob asked me to edit down the upgrade he gave me to work off of so that we can add it to the library for future HTS-GS1 users to benefit from, and I want to give back for all of the help the JP1 community has given to me, so I'm happy to do it.
I just want to make the best upgrade I can. I was able to figure out the discrete input buttons, so all I'm missing are those three, the SR+, the S. Retriever, and the MCACC. I was asking you about the OBC's because you had been helpful before when I was working on the discrete on/off issue, and you guys clearly know more of the advanced stuff than I do (but I'm getting there), so I thought you might know something here that I don't.
Rob: I can't remember if I tried that upgrade directly, but I think I did and I didn't have any luck. But I will definitely try again just to be certain. I KNOW I tried making those commands in my upgrade using the OBC's given, but using device code 166 instead of 165, and that didn't work.
It's my guess that it's brute-forceable; looking at the upgrade as I have it now, the other audio commands (Setup, Sound, Surround, et. al.) consistently use no prefix device or command and device 166. if I made an upgrade with all of the OBC's between 0 and 255 in device code 166 that your original upgrade didn't have, I think I'd stumble across it. And that might, thinking about it, be pretty easy to do; it would just be a lot of work to enter it all into RM.
I uploaded what I have to this point to:
https://www.hifi-remote.com/forums/dload ... le_id=6049
I probably should have zipped in that picture of the original remote I took. I left the device as DVD 1525 because that's what it was in the upgrade Rob gave me to start from, even though it's really an audio device, because I didn't know if I can just change it in the drop-down up in the corner of RM without breaking things. And I'd like to add the Xbox Media Remote keys, but I suspect I'd have to do that with keymoves, and since that's a custom upgrade unto itself, I don't know if I can do that.
So, summary: My Harmony One is working perfectly. (I wish there was a way to pull the IR information I need off of it!) I just want to make a good and complete upgrade to help future JP1 users.
I just want to make the best upgrade I can. I was able to figure out the discrete input buttons, so all I'm missing are those three, the SR+, the S. Retriever, and the MCACC. I was asking you about the OBC's because you had been helpful before when I was working on the discrete on/off issue, and you guys clearly know more of the advanced stuff than I do (but I'm getting there), so I thought you might know something here that I don't.
Rob: I can't remember if I tried that upgrade directly, but I think I did and I didn't have any luck. But I will definitely try again just to be certain. I KNOW I tried making those commands in my upgrade using the OBC's given, but using device code 166 instead of 165, and that didn't work.
It's my guess that it's brute-forceable; looking at the upgrade as I have it now, the other audio commands (Setup, Sound, Surround, et. al.) consistently use no prefix device or command and device 166. if I made an upgrade with all of the OBC's between 0 and 255 in device code 166 that your original upgrade didn't have, I think I'd stumble across it. And that might, thinking about it, be pretty easy to do; it would just be a lot of work to enter it all into RM.
I uploaded what I have to this point to:
https://www.hifi-remote.com/forums/dload ... le_id=6049
I probably should have zipped in that picture of the original remote I took. I left the device as DVD 1525 because that's what it was in the upgrade Rob gave me to start from, even though it's really an audio device, because I didn't know if I can just change it in the drop-down up in the corner of RM without breaking things. And I'd like to add the Xbox Media Remote keys, but I suspect I'd have to do that with keymoves, and since that's a custom upgrade unto itself, I don't know if I can do that.
So, summary: My Harmony One is working perfectly. (I wish there was a way to pull the IR information I need off of it!) I just want to make a good and complete upgrade to help future JP1 users.